- Startup
- Investor agent
- Corporate or company
We spoke with Johan Morales, VC & Impact Investing Investor.
In a context where an increasing number of entrepreneurs, investors, and institutions are backing models that combine profitability and impact, understanding the criteria that truly make a difference has become essential. We spoke with Johan Morales, an impact investing specialist, about how he evaluates startups in their early stages, the most common mistakes he sees founders make, the trends reshaping the sector, and the challenges the ecosystem must address to continue growing.
When you analyse an impact startup in a first meeting, what are the two or three signals that make you think impact is genuinely integrated into the business model rather than added as a commercial argument?
To understand the relationship between business and impact, there is one key question: is there a positive correlation between sales and impact generation? We often think that there are different ways of generating impact through different business models, but, conceptually, there is one fundamental idea: every additional sale generated by the company should also result in an increase in its social or environmental impact.
Within the impact investment world, this is known as the lockstep model, which is precisely based on this positive relationship between impact generation and sales.
There are also other important considerations, although for me they are not as decisive as this one. One of them is the team’s intentionality from day one. In other words, to what extent impact generation is genuinely part of the company’s purpose, or whether it is simply a positive externality resulting from its activity.
This also brings us to the difference between sustainability or ESG and impact. Sustainability often responds more to compliance or responsible-management issues, whereas impact involves something measurable, intentional and scalable.
To give a specific example, one of our portfolio companies is Basic & Medical. It applies artificial intelligence to medical-image analysis and functions as a kind of copilot for radiologists. Every time it sells its solution to a hospital or healthcare network, it helps more professionals diagnose certain conditions more quickly and efficiently. There is a direct relationship here between business growth and impact in healthcare.
When a startup is still validating its proposition, what evidence helps you trust that the impact it promises is beginning to materialise?
I think it is worth putting this question into context based precisely on the stage the company is at. At such an early stage, many things are still taking shape. The business vision is not entirely clear, and often neither is the impact vision. As an investor, I completely understand this context, so I am not going to expect an entrepreneur to have everything fully defined.
For me, what matters is having a vision or a logical map. There are tools such as the theory of change that are often perceived as something investors request for compliance or bureaucratic reasons, but that is not really the point. The aim is to understand the causality between the company’s key activities, its beneficiaries, its customers and the outcomes it wants to generate.
At these early stages, it is enough for me that you have a clear understanding of the logical causality between what you sell, how you are going to sell it, who you are targeting and how all of that is connected to the social or environmental outcomes you aim to create.
A startup is “messy”. Every day is different, things are constantly changing and, therefore, the impact model also evolves. That is why one of the things that helps me validate that you are on the right path is precisely having this logical map or theory of impact, together with a robust understanding of who your beneficiary is and what problem you are solving.
It is also important to observe how the end user or beneficiary responds. Are they really the person benefiting from the impact proposition? Is there a change in behaviour as a result of the solution?
And there is one question that I consider especially relevant: what would happen if the company did not exist? This is known as the counterfactual. If the company disappeared tomorrow, would things remain exactly the same, or would there be a real difference? When you can answer that question, you begin to understand whether there is genuine impact attribution associated with the company’s core activity.
Ultimately, I return to the initial point: we are talking about very young companies. I do not expect them to have everything completely resolved, but if they have these main elements in place, it gives me confidence as an investor. They may not yet have all the answers, but I can see that they are heading in the right direction. Moreover, part of the work of impact funds and investors is precisely to support entrepreneurs and help them systematise all these aspects as the company grows, because impact also needs processes, measurement and structure in order to be managed properly.
Some projects show strong financial potential but raise doubts regarding impact. What inconsistencies do you identify most often when the dual return is not properly constructed?
Before answering, I think it is worth clarifying from which perspective I am assessing the startup. It is not the same to analyse a company that was founded with a very clear impact mission from the outset as it is to analyse a more generalist company operating in a sector with positive effects.
For example, a company that develops automation systems for hospitals may indirectly contribute to improving the efficiency of the healthcare system, but that does not automatically make it an impact company. Operating in the healthcare sector does not turn a company into an impact company.
When I am analysing a company that does present itself as an impact startup from day one, one of the first questions I ask myself is: if I remove impact from the equation, would the business plan continue to work exactly as before? If the answer is yes—if sales and growth would not change even if the impact proposition disappeared—then something is conceptually wrong. In that case, we would be talking more about a conventional business with positive externalities than a genuine impact company.
Another common inconsistency appears when only the benefits of the solution are highlighted, while potential negative externalities or rebound effects are ignored.
Continuing with the healthcare example, an artificial-intelligence company focused on medical diagnosis can help detect diseases earlier and more efficiently, but it is also necessary to analyse issues such as false positives, false negatives or potentially incorrect recommendations that could affect clinical decision-making. If these risks are not taken into account, the impact perspective is incomplete.
Ultimately, what matters is understanding the relationship between business and impact and checking that both are moving in the same direction.
An example of a well-constructed dual return would be a company that helps large industrial companies reduce their energy consumption and whose business model consists of charging a commission based on the savings generated. The more energy it helps the client save, the more money the client saves and the more revenue the startup generates. There is a very clear relationship here between business growth, scalability and impact.
By contrast, a startup that sells software for preparing sustainability reports cannot assume that it generates more impact simply because it increases its number of customers. Having more customers does not necessarily imply a reduction in emissions or a tangible improvement in social or environmental outcomes. In this case, commercial growth and impact are not necessarily connected.
In your experience, what mistakes do startups typically make when trying to measure and demonstrate their impact? What should they do differently from the earliest stages?
I believe that the concept of intentionality is vital here. If your vision as an entrepreneur and founding team is to build a profitable company that also generates social or environmental impact, regardless of the sector, there are certain things you inevitably need to consider from day one.
For example, a key issue is the ability to measure impact. You cannot claim to be generating a particular impact if you do not have a system—ideally technology-based and involving as little friction as possible—that enables you to measure your progress towards those objectives. Whether we are talking about emissions reductions, job creation, access to healthcare or any other area, it has to be measurable.
There is then the question of how to measure and how far to go. Some founders try to measure absolutely everything and end up managing dozens of indicators. If everything matters, ultimately nothing matters. The opposite also happens: teams that measure almost nothing and therefore fall short. I believe the challenge is to find the right balance.
Another important aspect is understanding that a good founding story or a strong personal motivation is not enough. It is very positive for a project to have a reason for being behind it, but a company is still a company. Otherwise, it could be a foundation, an NGO or another type of organisation, all of which also fulfil a very valuable function.
If you decide to build a company—especially an impact company—you have to keep the return on investment firmly in mind. Ultimately, customers will not hire you simply because you are helping to make the world a better place. They will hire you because you demonstrate that you can help them reduce costs, generate revenue or solve a relevant problem efficiently.
It is also important to understand that impact management evolves with the company. A two- or three-year-old company does not face the same challenges as a more mature organisation. The approach to measuring, monitoring and managing impact changes over time.
As companies grow, more complex debates emerge. One of them is what is known as mission drift: the extent to which business growth is prioritised over impact generation. These are conversations that tend to arise at more advanced stages and require constant reflection.
So, if I had to summarise it, I would say that from the earliest stages, attention must be paid to four key elements: measurement, scalability, intentionality and the ability to adapt the impact model as the company evolves. These are issues that founders need to keep in mind and that investors also analyse very carefully.
Over the past year, what trends have you been observing in the field of impact investing?
I think it is worth starting with some context. Impact investing is part of a much broader market and is connected to what is happening in venture capital, private equity, public markets and even global dynamics originating in the United States or other ecosystems. Therefore, before talking only about impact investing, it is necessary to understand the broader context.
And within that context, there is one trend that stands above all the others: artificial intelligence. It is permeating every sector, including the impact ecosystem. I think we are seeing how AI is rewriting many of the rules of the game, both in terms of business models and value creation.
One example is the SaaS model. Some people say it is dead, while others believe it is simply being reinvented. I belong more to the second group. I believe that artificial intelligence is expanding the possibilities of models like this and changing how companies generate revenue and deliver value to their customers.
There is growing discussion of models in which customers do not pay solely for access to a platform or subscription, but for the results achieved. Some leading international funds are even suggesting that the next major technology company could be a services company presented as software, where what is actually being paid for is the results it delivers.
That is why I believe artificial intelligence is a fundamental trend. We are all trying to understand its real scale and the extent to which it will transform the economy. It is also creating uncertainty, because it is forcing entrepreneurs, investors and other ecosystem stakeholders to adapt quickly.
In addition, AI is forcing many startups to rethink their value proposition. If a company limits itself to developing a specific feature and a major platform incorporates that same capability natively, it risks being pushed out of the market. This requires everyone to move very quickly, both founders and investors.
Beyond artificial intelligence, we are also seeing how geopolitics is influencing investment priorities. Some sectors are becoming strategic for the next phase of the global economy, such as energy, data centres and all the technologies that enable this infrastructure to function.
In this regard, we are seeing interest in areas such as energy efficiency, cooling technologies and, more generally, all those solutions that act as fundamental components of the new digital economy.
There is also considerable interest in technologies with broad applicability across different sectors. In other words, solutions that offer multiple use cases and therefore have access to larger markets and greater growth optionality.
In short, artificial intelligence is probably the major theme redefining the market, but we are also seeing strong capital attraction towards strategic sectors linked to technological infrastructure, energy and solutions capable of generating value in multiple contexts.
Public administrations are increasingly promoting initiatives related to sustainability, innovation and impact. What role should they play?
Before addressing the question, it is worth taking a step back and understanding that Spain is part of a European market, which in turn is connected to a global market. Public funding does not exist in isolation; it is connected to everything that is happening in these ecosystems.
That said, I believe there is a question of mindset and of understanding the role that public administrations should play. In my view, public administrations can be much more than mere funders. There is sometimes a perception that their role is simply to provide financial resources, but I believe their real added value goes much further.
For me, the challenge is to move from being funders to becoming market builders. In other words, not just providing money, but contributing to building the market. This involves creating infrastructure, fostering cohesion among the different stakeholders, facilitating collaboration with the private sector and developing mechanisms that allow the ecosystem to operate more efficiently.
It is also important to understand that the public and private sectors have different strengths. The aim is not to compare them, but to identify what each can contribute. In the case of public administrations, one of their greatest strengths is precisely their ability to create the foundations on which markets can later develop.
As for public capital, I believe its impact is especially significant when it is used to take on risks that private capital cannot or does not want to assume. This includes instruments such as guarantees, first-loss mechanisms, co-investments and programmes that support the development of specialised funds.
The aim is not to replace private investors or replicate their role, but to complement them strategically. In fact, one of the major advantages of public capital is its multiplier effect. When used effectively, it can mobilise a much greater amount of private investment and generate a far broader impact on the real economy.
That is why I believe the debate should not focus solely on how much money is allocated to the ecosystem, but on how it is used. The important thing is to build a solid, efficient and sustainable market infrastructure that allows resources to generate a lasting effect.
Ultimately, everything starts with properly understanding the role public administrations can play, identifying the resources available to them and putting those resources at the service of the ecosystem in a strategic way. Rather than thinking only about the funds mobilised, we need to think about how to create a system that strengthens the market, generates continuity and prevents resources from being lost without producing a real long-term effect.
What differences do you observe between Spain and other more developed ecosystems in impact investing?
I think there are several differences, and it is worth analysing the issue in parts so as not to fall into generalisations. When we talk about impact-investment ecosystems, we are talking about many different stakeholders: the public sector, the supply of capital, the demand for capital and intermediaries. Each plays a different role.
If we start with the public administration, I believe one of the most significant differences compared with more developed ecosystems is the degree of systemic support that exists. It is not necessarily a question of having more resources, but of using them differently. There are countries with greater public-private collaboration, more innovation in financial instruments and a more structured vision of how to strengthen the ecosystem.
I am thinking, for example, of the United Kingdom. I am not saying it is a perfect model, but there has been a more pioneering mindset in certain areas. We have seen banks, pension funds and insurers participate in impact-related initiatives, as well as innovative instruments such as Social Impact Bonds, in which investors receive a return linked to the achievement of specific impact objectives. These are examples of public-private collaboration that help build a stronger market infrastructure.
In this regard, I believe that public-administration involvement is one of the factors that most influences the strength of an ecosystem. When there is a systemic, long-term vision, the results tend to be better.
If we look at the demand for capital—that is, startups, scaleups and companies seeking funding—I also observe some differences related to mindset. Spain has excellent entrepreneurs, but sometimes I feel there is a lack of greater global ambition from day one: thinking big from the outset, building international companies and having a sense of urgency about competing globally.
I do not think this is an exclusively Spanish phenomenon; it is also found in parts of Europe. Meanwhile, in other ecosystems there is a greater tendency to think about global markets and international scalability from the very beginning.
That said, I also believe there are many positive things in Spain. We have talent, we have excellent entrepreneurs and there are increasingly more highly skilled professionals working in this field. In addition, we have a position that offers interesting opportunities, and we must be able to play to our own strengths as an ecosystem. As I said, it is about understanding where we are, identifying what we are missing and moving further in that direction.
In terms of good practices, I believe there are several examples worth observing: from pension funds with specific impact mandates to wholesale banks supporting these types of initiatives, as well as schemes in which the public sector absorbs part of the risk in order to mobilise private investment.
I also see considerable potential in the role of foundations and in collaborative models involving different ecosystem stakeholders. These dynamics are already gaining traction in Spain and make me quite optimistic.
Ultimately, I believe there is room to continue strengthening the ecosystem, but I also see many highly capable and committed people who have the ability to take it to the next level over the coming years.
What would need to happen for impact investing to stop being considered a specialised segment?
It is a complex question, but I believe that, to a large extent, the answer can be summed up in one word: results.
We need more success stories, more proven returns and more examples demonstrating that impact is serious and can also generate financial returns. We need exits, returns and successful track records that demonstrate that this type of investment works and can compete with any other investment strategy.
As these success stories begin to accumulate, a snowball effect is created. More capital arrives, more intermediaries and specialised funds emerge, and the ecosystem begins to grow by itself. This is how markets that were once new become established.
I also believe we have evolved considerably in how we understand impact. It is no longer enough to say that a company is aligned with certain SDGs or operates in a social or environmental field. What matters is demonstrating that there is a clear return for customers, that the solution creates economic value and that, at the same time, it produces measurable social or environmental outcomes.
Furthermore, it is increasingly clear that impact is not an additional or accessory element. It is connected to some of the major economic and strategic challenges of our time: energy, data, technological sovereignty, value-chain resilience and many other issues that form part of today’s economy.
Another fundamental aspect is talent. Ultimately, every ecosystem depends on people. Attracting more talent requires economic, professional, social and cultural incentives. We must demonstrate that an impact-oriented organisation can compete for talent, offer attractive opportunities and develop first-class professional careers.
And, of course, all of this starts with founders. I always say that entrepreneurs are the heroes and heroines of this ecosystem. If we remove them from the equation, there is nothing left. They are the people who turn an idea into a product, build a company, develop technology and scale it.
I also believe that we need to talk about profitability as a matter of course. This is about generating impact, but also about generating business. We must demonstrate that it is possible to build strong companies while helping to solve problems related to healthcare, education, access to water, sustainability or any other major social or environmental challenge.
And perhaps the most important thing is to remember that behind all these metrics, investments and spreadsheets there are people. One of the most rewarding things is being able to speak with the end beneficiaries of the companies in which you invest and see that impact does not remain confined to a report or an indicator, but genuinely helps improve lives, strengthen communities and protect the ecosystems on which we depend.
That is why I believe the future of impact investing lies in demonstrating, with ever greater evidence, that profitability and impact are not incompatible objectives, but two elements that can reinforce one another.